An Indian woman living in Dubai,
Anamika Rana
, recently faced intense backlash on social media after posting a video in which she expressed her frustration with her maid's behavior. The video shows Rana catching her maid "slouching on the sofa" while using her phone, a situation that she filmed and later shared online. In the video, Anamika questions her followers about how she should handle the situation and set boundaries with her maid.
This video went viral and sparked an array of mixed reactions on social media, dividing users into those who supported Rana’s complaint and others who found her reaction to be overly critical of her maid. The incident highlights the ongoing debate about the treatment of domestic workers, the dynamics of employer-employee relationships, and the
role of social media
in amplifying personal complaints.
Anamika Rana expresses concern over maid 'slouching on sofa' and generational gaps in Instagram video
In the video posted on Instagram, Anamika Rana introduces the issue by directly addressing her followers: “How would you react?” She goes on to explain that she had caught her maid on camera, casually lounging on the sofa and using her phone. This was a situation that apparently surprised her, as she expected her maid to behave more formally in the house. Rana further adds a generational context to the situation, explaining that she is a millennial while her maid is from Generation Z, and thus their views and behaviors may differ.
Rana also mentioned that she was unsure about how to handle the situation, admitting that she wasn't "pro at maid handling." She asked her followers for guidance on how to establish appropriate boundaries with her maid, unsure of what was reasonable or acceptable in this situation.
Social media backlash against Anamika Rana's complaint about maid's behavior
As expected, the video quickly gained traction on social media, and the reactions were overwhelmingly critical. Many viewers were quick to call out Anamika for her complaint, arguing that it was unnecessary to focus on such a trivial issue. One commenter asked, “Why can’t she sit on the sofa?” suggesting that it was unreasonable for Anamika to take issue with her maid relaxing in the living room. Another user added, “Why would you have an issue with her sitting on the bed?” This sentiment was echoed by several others, who pointed out that treating domestic workers with respect and equality includes allowing them to rest and relax in the same spaces as the family.
Other users shared their own experiences, noting that they have a much more relaxed relationship with their domestic workers. One individual shared that they allow their maid to sit on the sofa and even have breakfast with the family. This comment emphasized the importance of not discriminating against workers based on their job or social status. Another commenter offered a more general piece of advice: “Treat her the way you want to be treated by others.”
Support for setting boundaries with domestic staff in the complaint
While the majority of comments were critical of Anamika's complaint, there were also those who supported her perspective. Some people argued that it was acceptable to set boundaries with domestic staff and that the maid’s behavior might have been crossing a line. One user suggested that sitting on the sofa was fine, but "slouching and getting comfortable" was not. This user advised Anamika to compare the maid’s behavior to that of her family members—explaining that no one in the house would slouch on the guest sofa, and therefore, the maid should be expected to follow the same standards. This advice was based on the notion that setting clear boundaries was important in maintaining order and discipline.
Another commenter defended the importance of having firm boundaries with domestic workers, especially when it came to personal spaces like the sofa or bed. They emphasized that while being kind and generous to help was important, it was also crucial to maintain a level of authority to avoid being taken for granted. This user shared their personal experience, stating that being too lenient with domestic help in the past had led to problems.
Social issues and power dynamics in the employer-employee relationship
The reactions to Anamika's video highlight deeper social issues, particularly related to class, power dynamics, and cultural expectations. In many parts of the world, including the Middle East, domestic workers are often seen as belonging to a lower social class, and their roles can be defined by strict boundaries set by their employers. The argument for allowing domestic workers to relax in shared spaces like the sofa touches on the broader theme of equality and respect in the employer-employee relationship. Supporters of the maid’s right to relax point out that there should be no discrimination based on job roles, suggesting that workers are entitled to similar comforts as the people they work for. On the other hand, those who support setting boundaries argue that there is an inherent hierarchy in the employer-employee dynamic, especially in private domestic settings. They believe that such boundaries help maintain professionalism and discipline in the workplace, even when the workplace happens to be a private home.
Role of social media in amplifying personal grievances and domestic worker boundaries
Anamika's decision to share her complaint on Instagram also speaks to the larger role social media plays in amplifying personal grievances. What may have started as a private frustration with her maid turned into a public debate, as thousands of people weighed in on the issue. Social media platforms, particularly Instagram, offer users a space to share personal experiences and seek advice from their followers. However, this can also lead to unwanted scrutiny when the content is controversial or criticized by the public. In this case, the video sparked strong reactions, leading Anamika to become a focal point for discussions on domestic worker rights, boundaries, and the complexities of social class.
Also Read | "How to Not Smell Like Curry”: NRI woman shares tips on avoiding curry smell; sparks debate online
English (US) ·